The short answer
A Stuck Float Switch Is the Most Common Culprit
The float switch is a plastic or metal ball that rises with the water level to activate the pump. It can get jammed against the side of the pit or snagged on debris, preventing it from dropping and signaling the pump to stop. Sometimes, the float arm itself can bend or become misaligned. Carefully checking and freeing the float mechanism is the first step in troubleshooting.
A Clogged or Frozen Discharge Line
The discharge pipe carries water away from your home. If this line becomes clogged with mud, leaves, or other debris, the water has nowhere to go and recirculates back into the pit. In colder climates, the line can freeze shut. Your pump will keep running, trying to push water through a blocked pipe. Inspect the line's exit point outside your home for any visible obstructions.
Issues with the Pump or Its Components
The internal on/off switch connected to the float can wear out or fail, leaving the pump stuck in the 'on' position. Less commonly, the pump impeller could be damaged or the unit itself may be undersized for the volume of water entering the pit. An old or worn-out pump may simply lack the power to move enough water to lower the level and trigger the shutoff.
- Stuck or snagged float switch.
- Clogged discharge line or frozen pipe.
- Faulty mechanical or pressure switch.
- Oversized pit allowing the float to swing freely.
- Undersized pump for the water volume.
- Damaged impeller or worn-out motor.
Immediate Steps You Can Take
First, unplug the pump from its electrical outlet for safety. Manually lift the float to see if the pump turns on, then release it to see if it turns off. This tests the switch. Check the discharge line outside for blockages. If you can safely clear a simple clog or release a stuck float, you may resolve the issue. If not, you will need professional help.
When to Call for Professional Help
If basic troubleshooting does not stop the pump from running, the problem is likely electrical or mechanical. A continuous-running pump is a sign of imminent failure. Local water damage pros have the tools and expertise to diagnose pump issues, clear deep clogs, or recommend a proper replacement.
Attempting a repair on a complex pump mechanism or its wiring without proper training can be hazardous. The pros can determine if the issue is with the switch, the motor, the discharge line, or if the entire system is improperly sized for your home. They can also check for less obvious problems, like a high water table overwhelming the system or a check valve that has failed.
Water damage does not wait
Water keeps spreading into floors and walls, so it is worth acting early. Calls are answered 24/7.
Call Now (561) 794-2954Frequently asked questions
Can a sump pump burn out from running nonstop?
Yes, absolutely. A sump pump motor is not designed for continuous operation. Running without stopping generates excessive heat, which will eventually cause the motor to overheat and fail. This leaves your home unprotected from water intrusion at the worst possible time. Replacing a burned-out motor often costs as much as a new pump unit.
Should I just replace the pump if it won't turn off?
Not necessarily. Often, the issue is a simple fix like a stuck float or clog. However, if the pump is over seven years old or the motor itself is faulty, replacement is usually more cost-effective than repair. A professional can assess the specific cause and the condition of the discharge line and pit to give you the best option.
Will my homeowners insurance cover water damage from this?
It depends on the cause and your specific policy. Sudden, accidental discharge from a plumbing failure may be covered, but gradual seepage or lack of maintenance often is not. Policies vary, and your insurer decides what is covered. You should review your policy and document the damage.